TL;DR: Rental arbitrage means renting a property long term and subletting it as a short-term rental on platforms like Airbnb. With around $5,000, you can cover first month’s rent, deposit, and basic furnishings to launch your first unit — as long as subletting is legal in your area and you plan for seasonality and vacancy gaps.
Rental arbitrage is arguably the newest frontier of the vacation rental business. As an industry, the short-term rental space is constantly shifting, and rental arbitrage is one of the most accessible ways to get into the game. You can start your business with around $5,000 and build toward a multi-property portfolio with relatively low capital risk compared to property ownership.
What is rental arbitrage?
Rental arbitrage is a business model where you lease a property long-term and sublet it as a short-term rental, keeping the difference between what you pay in rent and what you earn in nightly stays. You don’t own the asset, but you do take on the operational and legal responsibility.
Before starting short-term rental arbitrage on platforms like Airbnb or Vrbo, check local short-term rental regulations and your lease to confirm subletting is permitted. Getting into the fine print: the setup process can be complex, but the core idea is simple enough that you can start your own rental arbitrage business with just $5,000.
Before getting into the cost breakdown, it’s worth looking at the pros and cons. If you’re going to rent a property to sublet it as a vacation rental, you need to know the potential risks and benefits upfront.
Pros of rental arbitrage
Lower initial investment
One of the biggest advantages of rental arbitrage is the low startup cost compared to buying property.
Example budget in a mid-priced market:
- $2,000 first month’s rent
- $1,000 deposit (50% of monthly rent)
- $2,000 for basic furnishings and supplies (IKEA, Craigslist, Facebook Marketplace)
- Total: ~$5,000
Actual amounts vary by market — rent levels, deposit requirements, and furnishing standards all affect your real number. But the barrier to entry is significantly lower than traditional real estate investment.
Tip: Try to ensure that almost every couch in your rental is a sleeper sofa. This allows you to accommodate more guests and charge extra person fees, which can add $50 per person to your booking.
Lower capital risk
You’re not carrying a mortgage. But “lower risk” doesn’t mean “no risk”. You’re still responsible for monthly rent whether you have bookings or not, complying with local short-term rental regulations, and covering potential guest damage beyond what platforms reimburse. Still, your maximum exposure is typically your deposit and outstanding lease obligations rather than a six-figure property investment.
Diverse property portfolios
Since you’re not purchasing properties, your rental portfolio can include a wide variety of property types — apartments, houses, townhomes, even chalets if you’re in the right market. This lets you test what works in your area before committing significant capital.
For example, a new operator might test a 1-bed apartment downtown, a 2-bed near a stadium, and a suburban townhouse to see which property type and location performs best before doubling down on a specific niche.
Stronger profit margins on operations
With rental arbitrage, you’re not paying for property maintenance reserves, property taxes, or mortgage interest. These costs are built into your monthly rent. Lower overhead creates room for stronger profit margins on a per-booking basis—though your net margin depends heavily on occupancy rate and average daily rate (ADR).
Cons of rental arbitrage
Finding willing property owners
Most property owners who are willing to have their property run as a vacation rental would rather manage the process themselves — or they already are. However, some prefer a guaranteed monthly rent check and simply don’t have the time or interest to manage a short-term rental operation. These are your target landlords.
Legal complexity
Legal requirements can make rental arbitrage tricky—or illegal—if you don’t do your homework. The main dimensions to check:
- Lease permissions: Does your lease explicitly allow subletting?
- Building/HOA rules: Does your building or HOA permit short-term rentals?
- Local zoning and STR laws: Is short-term rental arbitrage legal in your municipality?
- Licensing and taxes: Are you properly licensed and remitting all required occupancy taxes?
Local government ordinances, state laws, and even building regulations vary widely. Make sure you’ve read up on your local requirements and ensure you’re operating legally before signing any lease.
Inconsistent occupancy rates
Rental arbitrage doesn’t protect you from seasonality and booking gaps. Even though the property isn’t yours and the capital risk is lower, you still have to pay rent on a property that might sit empty during slow months.
Here’s how the math can swing: If your rent is $2,000 per month, a 70% occupancy rate at $180 ADR looks very different from a 40% winter occupancy at $120 ADR. Build both scenarios into your projections before signing a lease. Track your occupancy rate, ADR, and RevPAR (revenue per available rental) to understand your real performance.
A dynamic pricing tool like Guesty PriceOptimizerTM can help you adjust rates based on demand, staying competitive in slower months without discounting too aggressively.
Management time
If you set up vacation rentals across multiple properties, management time adds up fast, especially if you’re not using property management software or you’re working a full-time job alongside your arbitrage business.
Even two units can generate dozens of guest messages per week, back-to-back turnover cleanings, and regular owner check-ins. If you’re also working a 9-to-5, something will eventually slip. Starting with a single property is the best way to test whether you can handle the operational load before scaling.
How to keep your rental arbitrage business safe
One of the most important aspects of the rental arbitrage process is making sure you, the property owner, and the guest are all protected.
Safety checklist:
- Get written permission to sublet
- Put owner terms and any revenue split in writing
- Carry proper short-term rental insurance
- Maintain and inspect the property regularly
The property owner will likely want an in-depth leasing agreement where you either agree to a higher deposit to protect against damage costs. In some cases, they’ll ask for a percentage of your earnings.
Confirm that subletting is permitted
Before starting a rental arbitrage business, make sure subletting is allowed in your rental agreement or lease. Violating the lease agreement can lead to eviction or legal action.
Never sublet a property without the owner’s explicit written permission. Ask the owner to approve subletting in the lease itself or through a written addendum, and keep a copy with your other business documents. Verbal approval isn’t enough.
Put everything in writing
When dealing with complex business arrangements like rental arbitrage, always document everything. Having correspondence in writing protects you if a disagreement arises.
At minimum, your agreement with the property owner should clarify who pays for:
- Minor repairs (under a certain threshold)
- Major repairs
- STR licenses and occupancy taxes
- Any fines related to guest behavior or STR violations
Carry proper insurance
Rental arbitrage involves assuming the role of a landlord, which comes with its own risks and liabilities.
Look for a policy that covers short-term rental use, liability if a guest is injured, and damage to the owner’s property. Talk to a licensed insurance professional to confirm details—standard renter’s insurance typically doesn’t cover commercial subletting activity.
Set up a comprehensive guest agreement
A guest agreement helps protect you, the property owner, and your guests by outlining rules and responsibilities for all parties.
Include:
- Maximum guest count
- Quiet hours and noise policies
- No-party policy
- Smoking rules
- Any local requirements (like guest registration or parking restrictions)
- Check-in/check-out procedures
- Emergency contact information
Maintain the property proactively
As the subletting host, you’re responsible for keeping the property safe and clean for guests. Regularly inspect for damage, handle necessary repairs promptly, and provide all the amenities guests expect.
Communicate regularly with the property owner
Keep the property owner informed about the status of the property and any issues that arise. A short quarterly email summarizing occupancy, guest feedback, and upcoming maintenance goes a long way toward keeping owners confident in the arrangement.
How to pitch rental arbitrage to property owners
The goal isn’t to hide that you’re doing rental arbitrage—it’s to present it as a professional, well-managed arrangement that benefits the owner too.
It can be challenging to convince a property owner to agree to rental arbitrage, as they may be wary of potential risks. Here’s how to make your case:
Explain the potential benefits
Be clear and transparent about what’s in it for them: a steady stream of rental income, minimal vacancy risk, and the potential for above-market rent.
Offer higher rent
Property owners are often more willing to consider rental arbitrage if they can earn more than market rent. Offer to pay a premium in exchange for subletting rights.
Provide references
Build trust by providing references from previous landlords and proof of income showing you can pay rent reliably.
Present your operations plan
Clearly outline your cleaning standards, maintenance process, and guest screening approach so owners see you’re running a serious, well-organized business—not winging it.
Sample pitch: “I specialize in short-term rentals and can offer you guaranteed monthly rent above market rate, handle all guest issues and maintenance, and keep vacancy low. Here are references from my current landlords and my plan for cleaning, screening, and communication.”
Be open to negotiation
Be willing to adjust terms. Owners may have concerns you can address by adjusting the agreement or offering additional incentives like a higher deposit.
Analyze the market before you commit
Market research is critical when starting a rental arbitrage venture. Finding a viable location takes work because vacation rental market data isn’t always easy to access.
As a starting point, check last year’s average occupancy rate and ADR for similar units in your target area. If the projected revenue at conservative assumptions doesn’t comfortably cover rent and fixed costs, look at another market.
To accurately determine market viability, you need insight into average daily rate, occupancy trends, market supply, rental size distribution, and property types. Tools like DPGO’s Markets feature provide this data for free and can help you make informed decisions before signing a lease.
FAQ
It can be, as long as your lease, building rules, and local short-term rental laws all allow it. Requirements vary significantly by location. Always verify with local authorities or a legal professional before proceeding.
In a mid-priced market, roughly $5,000 covers first month’s rent, deposit, and basic furnishings. Higher-rent markets or properties requiring better furnishing standards will cost more.
Profit depends on your rent, occupancy rate, average daily rate, and operating costs. A well-run arbitrage unit in a strong market might generate $500–$2,000+ per month in profit after expenses, but results vary widely. Run the numbers for your specific market before committing.
The main risks are: legal issues if you don’t have proper permissions, vacancy during slow seasons while still owing rent, property damage beyond insurance coverage, and the time commitment required to manage bookings and turnovers.
Guesty’s talented marketing team is comprised of passionate professionals who share insightful industry knowledge and shape brand narratives. By bringing a diverse blend of expertise to the table, we are the visionary architects behind the Guesty brand and innovative campaigns that help people understand our product.
